Premium Ice Cream
Our premium ice cream is made daily with a 14% butterfat dairy mix for a truly homemade rich and creamy product. We create all of our own recipes and our ice cream is also egg free!
Italian Ice
Our Italian ice is our dairy free option. Italian ice is a sweet, frozen dessert made from water, sugar, and flavorings. It is churned during the freezing process to create a smooth, dense texture. You may know it as granita or water ice.
Edible Cookie Dough
Our edible cookie dough is house made with our very own recipe. We always offer Chocolate Chip and Brownie Batter, but you may find extra flavors available when you stop in. Just ask! This is egg free, but is NOT dairy or gluten free.
Floats
Traditional ice cream float. Choose any flavor ice cream and any flavor soda.
Icebergs
Italian ice floats. Choose any flavor Italian ice and any flavor soda.
Frozen Floats
Layers of Italian ice and ice cream. Choose any flavor ice and any flavor ice cream.
Sundaes
Choose any two flavors of ice cream, Italian ice, or Cookie Dough you like for your pick of one of five sundae flavor options!
Flights
Comes with four scoops, whipped cream, cherries, and sauce topping of your choice! Mix and Match between Ice Cream, Italian Ice, and Cookie Dough.
Shakes
Pick up to two flavors of ice cream for your shake. Includes whipped cream and a cherry on top.
Pints
Hand-packed to order or Grab & Go - our pints are a great way to take home your favorite flavors.
Want to know more about our Menu and in store pricing? Click the button below!
*Not all products may be available. Products & Prices will be updated as needed. Click Here for allergen information.
© 2026 IT'S FATE CREAMERY - ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.